Friday, September 07, 2007

The New Social Contract

By DAVID BROOKS

Published: September 7, 2007

In 1942, Franklin Roosevelt imposed wage controls on American companies. Unable to lure workers with higher salaries, many employers began offering health insurance and other benefits. Then, in 1952, officials at the Internal Revenue Service ruled that these benefits wouldn’t count as taxable income.

And so, accidentally, the modern American health and pension system was born.

The system, in which families received social protections through their employers, worked well for decades. But now it’s coming apart at the seams. The proportion of people insured is falling. Rising health care costs burden employers. Workers can’t chase opportunities because they can’t bring their health insurance packages with them.

As Jason Bordoff points out in the current issue of Democracy, the old employer-based social contract is eroding and the central domestic policy debate of our time is over how to replace it.

Some liberals, believing that government should step in as employers withdraw, support a European-style, single-payer health care system. That would be fine if we were Europeans. But Americans, who are more individualistic and pluralistic, will not likely embrace a system that forces them to defer to the central government when it comes to making fundamental health care choices.

And so some distinctly American social contract is going to be required. Beneath all the fluff of the campaign season, that’s what the domestic side of the presidential race is about. In early, halting and half-formed ways, several candidates are offering broad visions of a new social contract and plans married to those visions.

REPLACE THESE THREE LINES WITH THE REST OF YOUR POST
LEAVE THE SPAN and BR and id="more" TAGS WHERE THEY ARE
(If there IS no "REST OF YOUR POST" then DELETE both the SPAN tags, and the ID tag)

Few have thought about these matters as long or as well as Stuart Butler of the Heritage Foundation. Butler grew up in Shrewsbury, England, got a doctorate in American economic history in Scotland and became a U.S. citizen in 1996. As a result, he’s acutely aware of what makes American civilization unique, and which policies fit the national character.

As you read his work, you quickly see what priorities the new social contract should embrace. It should offer basic security, so Americans will feel comfortable enough to move around and seize new opportunities. It should demand reciprocity; if you contribute to society, you’re protected from catastrophes no one can control. It should foster personal responsibility, stimulating private savings and self-insurance among those who can afford it.

Finally, it should foster self-sufficiency; if people do slip and require government support, they should be induced to rebound and take care of themselves. If you are fortunate enough to be upper-middle class, you shouldn’t be rigging the game so you grab benefits that should properly be allocated to the needy.

Butler is no libertarian. He doesn’t believe individuals should just be given Health Savings Accounts and then sent off to shop for health care. Nor does he believe that the primary social relationship is between individuals and government.

He sees America as a thick society, and believes that unions, churches and community groups should be involved in health care and social support. He sees America as a decentralized society. The worst thing we could do is get the smartest people in a room and build one system from Washington. Instead, Washington should set parameters and states should be left free to innovate and compete.

He also sees society as a continuum between the dead, living and unborn. We shouldn’t disrupt the lives of those who are happy with the insurance they have. On the other hand, it’s immoral to shift the costs to our children and grandchildren. Long-term expenses should be calculated into every decision we make.

Butler’s specific health care plan is well-summarized at the Web site of the Hamilton Project. First, he would create tax-exempt “insurance exchanges.” These would be sponsored by trusted agents — unions, churches and other social groups. Organized like the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program, they would offer menus of coverage choices and create diverse risk pools.

Second, employers who did not offer their own coverage would oversee payroll deductions and tax withholdings, but they would no longer have to sponsor programs or make choices for employees. Third, Congress would offer a health care tax credit to families making up to 200 percent of the poverty level, and would tighten benefits for the affluent. Fourth, states could come up with their own ways to regulate this system.

This isn’t the laissez-faire social contract of the 19th century. But neither is it the centralized, big bureaucracy contract of the 20th century. It’s a contract that envisions society as a dense but flexible web of social networks, the perfect vision for 21st-century America.

23 comments:

Brooklyn Reader said...

I love the way David Brooks, and a whole host of like-minded commentators, assert their points: Pick some random thing, misdescribe it, and then use your own description as the basis for a prima facia argument.

In this case, demonizing saner systems of healthcare than our own and threatening Americans with loss of freedom of choice.

The British healthcare system is a case in point. Brooks doesnt bother to look at the reality of it before drawing a conclusion. The logical flaw in his argument is that he assumes that the National Health Service is the entirety of British healthcare. It isn't.

While the NHS is infinitely superior to what a very large number of Americans must face when they need care (ERs, clinics, or going without until things get more serious), it's not the only game in town. Britain has a well-established private healthcare industry, too, for those who can afford it. For those wanting a facelift or a tummy-tuck, or simply not to rub elbows with the commoners, there is plentiful care available at rates very competitive with those in the US.

With all basic needs taken care of by NHS, it is no surprise that in order to compete, private healthcare is priced lower than it would be here.

Including NHS, and their private healthcare system, Britons spend something like half per capita on healthcare for what most public health metrics show to be superior care, compared to our conglomeration of private healthcare, HMOs, public hospitals, Medicare, Medicaid, Veteran's Health, charity hospitals and public clinics.

Anonymous said...

David Brooks advocates a health care proposal that would promote several of the primary causes of today's current failed health care system.

A health care system succeeds when the health care system provides essential health care to the entire public. Universal essential health care is a minimum requirement for any health care proposal. The proposal offered by Mr. Brooks fails to provide essential health care for all Americans.

The administrative systems for the Canadian Health Care System and Medicare are considerably more efficient than the private American insurance system. The proposal offered by Mr. Brooks relies on the inefficient traditional American private insurance system.

Administrative insurance expense is a minimum for a single large pool
of individuals with a risk for future medical expenses similar to the general population. This minimizes the cost of underwriting insurance because the expected frequency of disease and associated medical expense are predicted more precisely. The proposal offered Mr. Brooks would rely on a multitude of less efficient diverse risk pools of insured individuals.

The marketing expense of many competing diverse insurance companies would increase cost but not improve health care. If we want a real market-based approach to health care, eliminate private insurance, establish a uniform standard benefits package, require providers to set their price for annual health care and let health care providers compete on price.

My concern with this health care proposal is that the proposal attempts to achieve a philosophical goal, retain features of the current health care system and support the existing private insurance system. Health care reform should be about providing appropriate quality affordable health care to all Americans.

Alex said...

"The worst thing we could do is get the smartest people in a room and build one system from Washington. Instead, Washington should set parameters and states should be left free to innovate and compete."

-this is awesome, government should harness the power of natural selection. let 50 states design the best plan rather than 1 federal government screwing things up

Jerry said...

cheap wedding gowns,
discount bridal gowns,
China wedding dresses,
discount designer wedding dresses,
China wedding online store,
plus size wedding dresses,
cheap informal wedding dresses,
junior bridesmaid dresses,
cheap bridesmaid dresses,
maternity bridesmaid dresses,
discount flower girl gowns,
cheap prom dresses,
party dresses,
evening dresses,
mother of the bride dresses,
special occasion dresses,
cheap quinceanera dresses,
hot red wedding dresses

lla said...

Ed hardy clothes in Hollywood is a very popular brand hot.Classic tattoo art and fashion classic elements included in the ed hardy clothing .Simple ed hardy t-shirts is also a work of art.Therefore it is not difficult to understand why a ed hardy shirts , simple lines is an array.Ed hardy sunglasses undoubtly are their necessary ornaments when go out. Ed hardy mens and ed hardy womens are very innovative in his admiration of the design.
Wholesale Handbags
Cheap Handbags
Womens Handbags
Cheap Purses
Designer Handbags
ralph lauren polo
burberry polo shirt

lla said...

Wilson k factor KTour the flexibility of a good tennis racket is suitable for all type, doubles, singles players. Wilson k six shoot better on the first rotation speed to produce a very good help.Babolat aeropro drive Racquets is Nadal's babolat tennis racket used.In many places to be able to buy cheap tennis racquets.Babolat pure drive is a Babolat be proud of the company products, and a large number of professional tennis players to choose from, coupled with near-perfect design and adapt wider.
ralph lauren polo
Burbrery Polo Shirts
Cheap polo shirts
wholesale polo shirts
ralph lauren polo shirts
cheap ralph lauren polos
discount ralph lauren polos
polo clothing

传斌 said...

replica Watches
replica Watches
replica Watches
fake Watches
knockoff Watches
replica Rolex Watches
replica Breitling Watches
replica Cartier Watches
replica Omega Watches
replica Tag Heuer Watches
replica Bell & Ross Watches
replica Panerai Watches
replica IWC Watches
replica Patek Philippe Watches
replica Chopard Watches
replica Gucci Watches
replica Corum Watches
replica Montblanc Watches
replica Jacob & Co Watches
replica A.Dunhill Watches
replica A.Lange & Sohne Watches
replica Alain Silberstein Watches
replica Audemars Piguet Watches
replica B.R.M Watches
replica Baume & Mercier Watches
replica Blancpain Watches
replica BMW Watches
replica Breguet Watches
replica Burberry Watches
replica Bvlgari Watches
replica Chronoswiss Watches
replica Concord Watches
replica D&G Watches
replica De Witt Watches
replica Dior Watches

Anonymous said...

Replica Handbags
Fake Handbags
Knockoff Handbags

Replica Louis Vuitton Handbags
Replica Gucci Handbags
Replica Chanel Handbags
Prada Handbags
Replica Fendi Handbags
Replica Dolce Gabbana Handbags
Replica Chloe Handbags
Replica Jimmy Choo Handbags
Replica Thomas Wylde Handbags
Replica MiuMiu Handbags

Replica Balenciaga Handbags
Replica Coach Handbags
Replica Lancel Handbags
Replica Hermes Handbags
Replica Marc Jacobs Handbags
Replica Anya Hindmarch Handbags
Replica YSL Handbags
Replica Mulberry Handbags
Replica Givenchy Handbags
Replica Valentino Handbags
Replica Versace Handbags
Replica Cartier Handbags
Replica Marni Handbags
Replica Bottega Veneta Handbags
Replica Loewe Handbags
Replica Kooba Handbags

Replica Bally Handbags
Replica Burberry Handbags
Replica Christian Dior Handbags
Replica Juicy Couture Handbags
Replica Ferragamo Handbags
Replica Celine Handbags

tolerance said...

cosplay costumes are in hot sales. As the time flying, more and more youngers like clothing of anime cosplay.These wholesale costume can be bought in our cosplay online store. Wholesale anime cosplay costumesand naruto cosplay costumes at discount price. I love everything and I was wondering how I could make a Japanese School Uniform. You'll need cloth of course probably navy or white for the majority. Costume of Final Fantasy Cosplay, Bleach Cosplay and Kingdom Hearts Cosplay has a feature article on the Japanese School Uniform fashion. We provide all kins of costumes of cosplay naruto, and these costumes of cheap cosplay are made of high quality materials.

Apa Saja Dah said...

Find and download what you need at Rapidshare Search Engine.
Top Site List Free Proxy Site Free Download mp3 Michael Jackson song All Michael Jackson Lirics Oes Tsetnoc Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa Download Mp3 Gratis

Opal said...

http://cellphones.blog.sohu.com
http://dressweddingstores.wordpress.com
http://wedding-dress-online.blog.anous.fr
http://wedding.blogge.rs
http://cellphones.blog131.fc2.com

Anonymous said...

hotel price compare
cheap hotels near disneyland
etoile trocadero hotel
hotel daniel
brayton hotel
cheap brighton hotels

JJ said...

thanks for your sharing! great helpful!!!Thank you
Wedding Dress Shops
Bridal Wedding Dresses
Cheap wedding dresses
cheap mobile phone

Anonymous said...

[url=http://remroom.ru]отделка домов квартир офисов[/url] Ремонт и отделка офисов, комнат или домов – это одна из актуальных в наше время проблема многих людей, решившихся, наконец, привести в порядок свой дом. Мало того, что улучшение – это занятие трудоемкое и напряженное, еще и найти заслуживающую доверия компанию, занимающуюся отделкой квартир или дач сегодня практически нельзя. Дело в том, что все меньше и меньше в Москве осталось фирм, делающих свою работу качественно, эффективно и недорого. [url=http://remroom.ru]кредит на ремонт квартиры[/url]
Однако наша компания является хорошим исключением из этого неприятного правила. Мы вот уже несколько лет занимается улучшением помещений, комнат, домов и еще ни разу нам не приходило от наших клиентов ни неприятных отзывов, ни каких-либо жалоб. [url=http://remroom.ru]сколько стоит ремонт квартиры[/url] Богатый опыт наших специалистов, а также высокий профессионализм всех без исключения наших работников, поможет сделать хорошо, качественно и – главное - доступно как косметический, так и капитальный ремонт. [url=http://remroom.ru]ремонт 2 х комнатной квартиры[/url] Современное оборудование, новые технологии планировки и дизайна, а также индивидуальный подход к каждому клиенту и гибкая система скидок сделали нашу компанию самой успешной на сегодня фирмой, оказывающей услуги улучшению и отделке помещений, комнат или дач. [url=http://remroom.ru]ремонт квартир под ключ прайс[/url]

appleling said...

I really like your site, it made me learn a lot and hope you come visit my site Wilson Tennis Racket, Cheap Tennis Racket Best Tennis Racket Wilson Tennis Rackets And Wilson Tennis Rackets ,Cheap Tennis Racquets,Cheap Tennis Racquets,Cheap Tennis Racquets.welcome to visit ugg classic sale,ugg classic sale,uggs clearance,uggs clearance.uggs clearance.ugg sequin boots.moncler jassen

Anonymous said...

Этот пост — одно из немногих исключений, когда читаешь с интересом и что-то для себя выносишь. Спасибо автору. Добавлю в избранное[url=http://voronezh.recikl.ru/].[/url] :)

Anonymous said...


"When we behave in ways that conflict with our judgment of what is appropriate, we lose face in our own eyes," explains Branden (p lumigan uk online What is known is that genetic, biological, environmental, and psychological factors can all play a role in triggering a mental health problem in some individuals
The company manufactures physical fitness machines like treadmills, elliptical machines, exercise bikes and others cheap cymbalta Children & adolescents are to be closely monitored if beginning antidepressants or changing dosage.

-Depression and insomnia Viagra for women pills If we are leaning towards acidic because of the things that we eat and drink, our body will not support life well
When the cause has been identified, several treatments may be given to help you cope with your anxiety attacks in a healthier way buy iressa In a child ADHD treatment can be very risky because of the numerous side effects from prescription drug
Never discontinue taking the prescription drug Xanax without a doctor's approval and recommendation Clarinex Most people buy these products on the false notion that you can alter your appearance by introducing new tissue through the skin

Anonymous said...

The simplest way to do this is just to visit your doctor/dermatologist and ask if there is a possibility of side effects that could occur with any acne treatment product you are using lumigan And you will not suffer that frustrating hunger feeling
They say it ultimately makes them smarter!Obviously, not enough of a warning has been brought to their attention or their pareants cymbalta It’s time to forget about autumn depression! Drive your sadness away today!
To avoid this, there are several ways to spice things up and keep healthy food tasty generic Viagra for women Meningitis can be caused by a wide range of bacteria, viruses and even fungi
Extracts from it have been shown to inhibit the breakdown of hyaluronic acid; one of the compounds that keep the skin smooth and soft iressa Do not alter any of the ingredients, and do not substitute the maple syrup with honey

Drink a lot of water through the day, 8 or glasses total Clomid online pharmacies Calculate your daily caloric needs and decide on how much you need to cut each day to start losing weight

Anonymous said...

That leaves two possibilities, and if you can remember the name brachioradialis, you should be able to figure out it is partly named for where it inserts, which is the radius buy viagra It would be a wiser choice to consider naturally regrowing your hair You will also want to make sure that your feet are about shoulder width apart in length cialis Penis Enhancement Pills SafetyCertain companies that sell penis enhancement pills claim that their products do not have any adverse effects on their users

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.magicaudiotools.com/convert-flac-to-mp3]flac to mp3 converter[/url]

Anonymous said...

generic ativan 1mg lorazepam compared to 1 mg of xanax - ativan online no prescription needed

Anonymous said...

cheap xanax xanax generic buy - xanax and alcohol psychosis

Anonymous said...

Производственная компания «М-СЕТ» специализируется на производстве сварных сеток в рулонах, имеющих широкое применение в различных строительных работах.
Производство сварной сетки выполняется на многоточечных сварных машинах, методом контактно-точечной сварки крестообразных соединений. Все пересечения и стыки прутьев тщательно сварены, благодаря чему конструкция отличается превосходным качеством и является одной из самых прочных.
На нашем сайте Вы можете посмотреть образцы нашей продукции и связаться с нами
[url=http://setka-vlg.ru/]сетка сварная кладочная 50х50
[/url]