Thursday, September 13, 2007

The Ottoman Swede

By ROGER COHEN

Published: September 13, 2007


STOCKHOLM


As members of Congress mull what to do next in Iraq, they might glance at a League of Nations report of July 16, 1925, on the new Middle Eastern state then being carved by the British from the wreckage of the Ottoman Empire.

The report said that despite “the good intentions of the statesmen of Iraq, whose political experience is necessarily small, it is to be feared that serious difficulties may arise out of the differences which in some cases exist in regard to political ideas between the Shiites of the South and the Sunnites of the North, the racial differences between Arabs and Kurds, and the necessity of keeping the turbulent tribes under control.”

And it warned: “These difficulties might be fatal to the very existence of the State if it were left without support and guidance.”

So much for things changing. They don’t, or only slowly, when attempts are made to carve sustainable nation states from multiethnic empires.

This 82-year-old document was handed to me by Carl Bildt, the Swedish foreign minister, a man of dry humor and quick tongue who can claim to be the world’s authority on messes in post-Ottoman areas. “From Bihac to Basra,” he said, referring to towns in western Bosnia and Southern Iraq, “these things take time and benchmarks don’t count for much.”

Bildt recently returned from Baghdad where Sweden has much to discuss given that 20,000 Iraqi refugees are expected to arrive here this year, a number that dwarfs the trickle of fleeing Iraqis into the United States. This imbalance is shameful, but that’s another story. Iraqis have no special desire to trade desert for pine forest, but Sweden has the merit of letting them in.

In the Iraqi capital, Bildt heard divergent political visions from Nuri Kamal al-Maliki, the Shiite prime minister, and Tariq al-Hashemi, the Sunni vice president. The notion of give-and-take, of compromise reached rather than domination imposed, is a Middle Eastern novelty.

Give-and-take has not been a big Balkan thing either, and it was in the Balkans, as a special European Union envoy, that Bildt cut his teeth on post-Ottoman mayhem. He sees “massive parallels” between Yugoslavia’s violent dismemberment once dictatorship ended and Iraq’s turbulent deliverance from tyranny.

Both states were invented in the post-World War I years in areas long under complete or partial Ottoman dominion. Both were beautiful inventions, bridges between divergent cultures and religions and ethnic groups, mosaics beneath a national flag. Both had the drawback of tending toward their own self-destruction in the absence of a strongman to resolve contradiction through force.

Freedom is a funny thing. Life without it is misery. But a glance at the Soviet Union or Yugoslavia or now Iraq is a sufficient reminder that distinct peoples forcefully gathered into a dictatorial state will react in the first instance to liberty by trying to get free of each other rather than trying to imagine a liberal democracy.

As Miroslav Hroch, the Czech political theorist, has observed, ethnic or religious nationalism easily become the “substitutes for factors of integration in a disintegrating nation.” That’s where we are in Iraq. In plotting a social revolution, the ushering to power of a subjugated Shiite majority through the overthrow of a minority Sunni dictatorship, the Bush administration did not ponder or plan for these realities.

That’s unfortunate, indeed unforgivable, but it’s done.

Bildt, Balkan-hardened, takes the long view. “If you take the Ottoman areas, they were Muslim but tolerant with an array of different cultures and their replacement with different versions of the 19th-century nation state has proved very difficult, be it in the Balkans, in Cyprus or the Middle East.”

He cannot imagine a quick American exit. “Iraqi leaders will want some sort of exit perspective, but a long-term one,” he says. As long as Iran and Saudi Arabia see Iraq as a Shia-Sunni battlefield, peace will be elusive.

The Balkan analogy is interesting. Yugoslavia’s breakup saw four years of war, then another war in Kosovo four years later. Only regional pressure — the bait of European Union membership — and a large European and American military presence have brought calm. The question of Kosovo’s independence from Serbia remains explosive.

This fragile stability is where the 16-year arc from the eruption of the Balkan wars in 1991 has led. Given that regional realities make an Iraqi breakup unthinkable, the architecture of the Yugoslavia-in-miniature in Bosnia is probably the most helpful guide for Baghdad: a fig-leaf national government presiding over a loose federation.

If the United States meets the responsibilities its invasion engaged and the region can be coaxed to help rather than hinder, we may attain such fragile stability 16 years from Saddam’s fall: that would be 2019, just over a century after the Ottoman collapse.

You are invited to comment at my blog: www.iht.com/passages.



9 comments:

r.mirman said...

Your column is quite correct. Unfortunately it is 4 years late. The question is what to do now. First recognize that all options are bad. All the terrible things that people are concerned about may well happen. But we are not going to remain there another couple of decades. That is another pure fantasy about Iraq, And the situation will not get better if we stay, no matter how long. This must be recognized before we can decide what to do next. Perhaps Saudi Arabia should move into the Sunni areas. They might be able to keep the peace among their co-religionists. Will Iran really go to war to stop them aiding the Sunnis, with no threat to the Shiites? Let us look at this realistically. For further comment see
randomabsurdities.wordpress.com

Anonymous said...

inn booking portal
[url=http://vimeo.com/user4498961]cheap hotels near disney world
[/url]conservation class s
caravanserai travel reviews
overnight conformation
[url=http://www.earthday.org/users/48490]cheap hotels lake district
[/url]acceptable house inferior ancestry
low-cost hotel prices
airlie shore motel
[url=http://www.fairview.org/cty/members/klemot/default.aspx]hotel gare du nord
[/url]borgata motor hotel
cheap house siren
hotel stelle
[url=http://www.youthcabinet.org/profile/Josh]taj hotel
[/url]daylesford accommodation
cheap kitchens
find hotel deals
[url=http://www.beautyresearch.com/blogs/alexa/archive/2010/08/15/hotels-and-accomodations.aspx]george hotel shipston
[/url]airport caravanserai deals
economical london guest houses
matheran hotel booking
[url=http://www.mazdacommunity.com/profiles/blogs/special-hotel-offers-or]cheap singapore hotels
[/url]amenities hotels
chintzy flights to canada
motor hotel regulations

Anonymous said...

conciseness vocation league
[url=http://vimeo.com/user4498961]price hotels
[/url]online mood booking
cheap line in canada
for nothing cover deals
[url=http://www.earthday.org/users/48490]rive gauche hotel
[/url]uiuc accommodation
cheap cd
economical building usa
[url=http://www.fairview.org/cty/members/klemot/default.aspx]hotel relais
[/url]valentine inn deals
online accommodation
worldwide flights booking
[url=http://www.youthcabinet.org/profile/Josh]first world hotel price
[/url]reasonable bird council
hotels near
gala facility
[url=http://www.beautyresearch.com/blogs/alexa/archive/2010/08/15/hotels-and-accomodations.aspx]the george hotel shipston on stour
[/url]base chicago b & b
soft-cover hotels
motel flight deals
[url=http://www.mazdacommunity.com/profiles/blogs/special-hotel-offers-or]1800 hotels
[/url]scrooge-like house indemnification
reasonable summer house
hostel

Anonymous said...

Wow neat! This is a really great site! I am wondering if anyone else has come across something
like this in the past? Keep up the great work!

Anonymous said...

A highly-appropriate couple of denim denim jeans appearance good on Ben Roethlisberger Jersey anybody. http://www.lateuggboots.com The dress consists of a bodice and skirt accompanied by a pair of ¾ exchange sleeves trimmed with lace. ghd hair straightener In this exhibition, she explores the narratives of the various neighborhoods that have had a lasting impression on her. ghd precious gift set Carbonetworks . http://www.softuggboots.com A widespread error made by men and women would be to overlook the wallet although likely out of the house or while leaving the workplace..

Anonymous said...

And that we, like a society always conscious of what is popular, follows dutifully along, wanting to buy the haveInch item of year. ugg boots Over the past (almost) year and the summer of 2009 that I've spent in the Atlanta area, I have heard similar (and worse) news casts about then Mayor Shirley Franklin. north face jackets on sale The design of chanel unique three-dimensional rhombic grid let the snake-effect suddenly appear most incisive. http://www.softuggboots.com And there are worse things than cooling your heels at an airport like this, which is basically a super sized mall. north face canada This will cover healthy relationships and staying safe, and will berun by Women's Health Matters, who deliver domestic violence support and educational work across Leeds.

Anonymous said...

I am your daughter, have said to make you happy daughter; You are my mother, my mother always loved. http://www.manyghdhair.com I not really experiencing all that much guilt about not having done the honest thing in taking them back to correct the error. http://www.verynorthface.com Make your first steps in watercolor fun and rewarding! Watercolor's vivid colors and fresh, direct brush strokes make it the most exciting way to paint. http://www.downuggboots.com Just be careful about going the business route, you could turn a hobby that you love, into a job that you hate. http://www.oneghdhair.com Traffic flows along the new extension from the 52 freeway to the 67 as you make your way from the west to travel to one our shops which offer the typical big box items as well as some of the most quaint antique shops you find anywhere.

Anonymous said...

The soldiers are all slaves. ghd straightener australia There is a variety and a fine collection of unique fashion Pashmina at this online site. ugg boots Silly me, what was I thinking? I was picturing loads of local restaurants and bakeries serving up little bits of food on toothpicks as samples or having mini cups of beverages and the like, perhaps selling regular-sized portions of their delicacies for a nominal fee. http://www.softuggboots.com The magazine is 95% editorial, but it is also 5% commerce. north face uk Have you heard of the University of the Arts? If you haven't, and you're interested in fashion then you soon will have! This is an umbrella organisation which runs several famous fashion schools including Central Saint Martins, and the London College of Fashion.

Anonymous said...

A great pair of shoes, perhaps not most likely the most gorgeous, not the priciest, neither is the emblem name, nonetheless it normally requires someone to tour the whole world, Christian Louboutin Sale
solve these questions . like the happiness shoes fail to fit, perhaps enviable,although the injured indeed.Asics Australia
A great situation you should have encountered, walked vertical in front of the display cabinets in countless sorts of shoes in reality dazzling, not in order to select. Price is best will never be beautiful, like costly, comfortable look out of fashion, feel good-looking persons who think old-fashioned ... grow to be completely happy about simply difficult. Pick to pick out, finally decided on a pair, wear 2 or 3 days only to realize foot wear, or completely to equal their clothes,Christian Louboutin Shoes
simple methods to do that time? To grant up'd rather painful to always wear?